How Private Equity Creates Value After an Acquisition

There is a version of private equity that exists mostly in people's heads. Investors buy a business, wait a few years, and sell it for more than they paid. The skill, in that telling, is entirely in the buying.

The reality is considerably more involved, and the difference matters because it is where most of the returns actually come from.

Choosing the right business is genuinely important — I have written elsewhere about what makes a business attractive to private equity in the first place. But experienced investors spend just as much time thinking about what happens after the acquisition closes, because in private equity, returns are created through execution rather than through the purchase itself.

The acquisition is the beginning, not the conclusion

From day one of ownership, the question shifts. It is no longer "what is this business worth?" It becomes "how do we make this business more valuable than it is today?"

That reframing is where value creation begins, and it starts long before closing. When our investment team is evaluating an opportunity, we are not only asking what the business is worth right now. We are asking what it could become, and — more importantly — what specific initiatives will get it there.

A business that looks identical to another on a summary page can be worth very different amounts depending on what an owner is actually able to do with it.

Where value actually comes from

Revenue growth is the most visible lever. Can we add customers? Expand geographically? Introduce new service lines? Enter adjacent markets? Strengthen referral relationships? Growth is usually part of the plan, and it is rarely enough on its own — which is a point I have made at some length on why revenue growth can be misleading.

Operational improvement is quieter and often more reliable. A great many lower middle market businesses have been built into genuine successes despite outdated systems, manual processes and workflows that were designed for a company a third of the size. Reporting needs improving. Technology needs modernizing. Processes need standardizing. Improving operational efficiency raises profitability and makes the business meaningfully more scalable at the same time.

Management development is the one people underestimate. As businesses grow they need stronger leadership structures, clearer accountability and better decision-making. Sometimes value creation is not about changing the business at all — it is about helping the management team build an organization capable of supporting the next stage of growth.

Margin improvement compounds quietly. Can purchasing be optimized? Can pricing be improved? Can overhead be reduced? Even relatively small movements in operating margin can increase enterprise value substantially over a hold period, because the improvement applies to every dollar of revenue that follows it.

Strategic acquisitions can expand capabilities, add scale, diversify the customer base and strengthen competitive position. Executed well, they accelerate both growth and value creation. Executed carelessly, they add complexity to a business that was working.

A plan that is not connected to the thesis is not a plan

One thing I often remind our associates is that value creation is not a collection of good ideas. The strongest plans I have seen are tied directly to the investment thesis.

If the thesis is built on geographic expansion, the value creation plan should be about expanding geographically. If the thesis depends on operational improvement, execution should be about operational excellence. The argument for buying the business and the plan for owning it are supposed to be the same argument.

When they come apart — when the memo says one thing and the hundred-day plan says another — it usually means the thesis was never fully formed. That is worth catching before closing rather than after, and it is one of the reasons building a real investment thesis is load-bearing work rather than a document produced for approval.

Prioritization is the discipline nobody mentions

Almost every business has dozens of opportunities for improvement. Identifying them is not the hard part — you can generate a list in an afternoon.

The challenge is deciding which few will create the most value, because management time is limited, capital is limited, and organizational attention is the most limited of all. A plan with fifteen priorities has no priorities, and the initiatives that get half-executed tend to cost more than the ones never started.

The best investors I know are unusually willing to leave good ideas on the table in order to finish the important ones.

Identifying value is far easier than creating it

This is the lesson that took me longest to internalize, and it is the one I would most want a newer investor to hear.

Building a list of improvement opportunities is relatively easy. Executing those initiatives consistently, over several years, through staff turnover and market shifts and the ordinary friction of running a company, is much harder.

Which is why execution matters. Management matters. Accountability matters. It is also why private equity investors spend so much time reviewing KPIs, running operating reviews, monitoring performance and refining strategic plans — the objective was never to produce a plan. The objective is measurable results.

A value creation plan that nobody is accountable for is a document, not a strategy.

The best investments are rarely the perfect ones

Something I have come to believe over my career: some of the best investments are not businesses that begin as perfect companies. They are businesses with meaningful room for improvement, where management, employees and investors can work together and build something better than what was bought.

That is a less romantic description of private equity than the one where the skill is all in the purchase. It is also, in my experience, the accurate one.

Because the work is not really about buying businesses. It is about building better ones.

Here is the full discussion from Episode 8:

Prefer audio? Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.